Gaines Street Pies was created by two local guys that wanted to create the best pizza in Tallahassee.

“Ingredient by ingredient and recipe by recipe, we worked until we found the very best. We started by using fresh ingredients. We got rid of the freezer and microwave and made homemade meatballs, real sliced bacon, fresh made ranch and followed this model for every ingredient on our menu. We brought in creative creations and mashed flavors together that have never been seen on pizza before.
When we opened and heard all of the feedback, we knew we had a hit. Less than a year later we launched our second location in Midtown. A year after that, we launched our third location.
We invite you to come in and try the flavor of a Gaines Street Pie!”

-Co-Founders/Owners, Jeremy Matlow & Ryan Smith

Now taking Reservations for parties of 8 or more at our Capital Circle Location! Our adjoining bar, Warhorse Whiskey Bar, provides semi-private space for up to 60 people.